DMarket vs ShadowPay
By MattCS · Updated 25 October 2026
DMarket scores higher overall (7.1 vs 5.3). DMarket is stronger on trust & reputation, payouts, pricing transparency, features, value & fees, design & ux.
Scores
6.5
Trust & reputation3.5
6.0
Payouts3.5
7.0
Pricing transparency5.5
8.5
Features7.5
8.0
Value & fees7.0
7.0
Design & UX6.0
Side by side
| DMarket | ShadowPay | |
|---|---|---|
| Categories | Trading | Trading |
| Bonus | ~2% selling fee | Marketplace + cash-out |
| Fees | 2% seller fee · instant sell 20% under market · ~12.5% trade spread | 5% seller fee · instant sell 17% under market · ~33% trade spread |
| KYC | Not stated | Not stated |
| Instant withdrawals | Not confirmed | Not confirmed |
| License | None stated | None stated |
| Founded | Not stated | Not stated |
| Features | P2P Marketplace, Trade bot, Instant Sell, Buy orders, CS2 skins, Rust skins, TF2 items | Marketplace, Instant Sell, CS2 skins, Rust skins |
| Deposit with | Card, Crypto, Skins | Card, Crypto |
| Withdraw with | Payoneer, PayPal, Bank transfer, Crypto | Crypto, Card |
| Trustpilot | 3.9/5 (22,157) | 3.4/5 (831) |
| Monthly visits | 2.62M | 119.3K |
Our verdict
DMarket is the better all-round pick, 7.1 against 5.3.
Players rate DMarket higher on Trustpilot: 3.9 against 3.4.
Pick DMarket if…
- + 2% sell fee on most CS2 skins listed through the bot, the same as CSFloat and far under Skinport's 8%
- + Buying runs about 2.6% above CSFloat in our September 2026 price data, cheaper than CS.MONEY or Skinport
- + Many payout routes: Payoneer at 0%, ACH at $1.27, card, PayPal, Skrill, wire, check and crypto
Pick ShadowPay if…
- + 5% seller fee; buying close to market
- + CS2, Dota 2 and Rust
- + Browser extension for selling